She asked me last night If I was a virgin. I told her the truth. She seemed pretty shocked.
Yeah, I'm not sure what your age is, but I'm assuming you are over 30? So I'd say over 95% of people or so have had sex by your age, so yeah, anyone is going to be surprised after hearing that someone your age is a virgin.
I mean I'm 27 and if I told a girl i've only had sex once she'd be surprised too.
You said earlier she doesn't care about the inexperience so I doubt it will effect your dating with her. She probably just needed to gather her thoughts because she probably hasn't been with a guy that is a virgin in years, or maybe ever.
That's what sucks about the way society operates, though. Most people see something as different and they get afraid of that. I have been rejected because of my lack of sexual experience before but I doubt you will.
What sucks about talking with people, especially in dating, is that people will sometimes lie so they don't make you feel bad. I'm not saying she's lying, but how she said it's cute that you are a virgin. Maybe she's telling the truth, but she also could be lying about that because she doesn't want to hurt your feelings. I've had a woman tell me that it's cute when she found out I was shy then all the sudden she cancels the date and doesn't want to see me anymore, haha. Sometimes it's tough to tell.
Hopefully it works out for you.