Yes, very much.
See, my first instinct is to save the person who loves me, because usually knowing that someone likes me is, attractive (maybe?) to me. But then there's the why don't I love them back, is it because I don't know they love me? If that's the case, I'd have no reason to pick her over the other. If I did know, there must be some reason for me not returning the feelings. This could be because of my feelings for the other person, which must be very strong.
Assuming I do know the feelings the person who loves me has, it makes me flip flop to the other person. This is because in order for me to have such strong feelings for them I must at least think they like me as well, because when knowing someone likes me is attractive knowing they don't is unattractive. I'm just insecure like that :
:. It states though that this person doesn't love me though, so either I don't know this, or I'm just completely infatuated, which isn't real love.
Continuing on the assumption I'm aware of each of there feelings, I would have to switch back to my initial instinct, the girl who love me but I do not love back. But then again, it's all really circumstantial, if this girl actually loves me there's a good chance she's crazy so maybe letting her drown would be the better option :
: All other things equal though, girl who likes me.