I think physically, I would give myself around an 8, maybe a 9. I'm about average height for a guy (5'9"). I have a muscular build and I weigh about 185-190 lbs. I didn't always think I was good looking. When I was growing up, I really wasn't into my looks that much. It wasn't until I was in my early 20s that I started to be aware of how I looked physically to others.
However, on a confidence scale, now I would give myself a 6 or 7. I used to be like a 2 or 3 in that department. I actually think that self-confidence outweighs physical appearance (most of the time). If you look good, but you are not confident in yourself, then others will see that and that would make you less attractive. Most women like men who are confident (not arrogant) in themselves. That is something that I have been struggling with every since I was a teenager. Now, I am getting better and I am beginning to be more confident in my ability to find a woman. I haven't actually done it yet, but at least my confidence is better!