Opinions on my Poem?

MaliceInWickedland

Well-known member
During English on Friday, we were assigned to do a free-verse poem that tells a story about a time in your life that "changed" you or your view on life and we have to present it to the class. My poem is called "A December to Remember" and it's about the day my father was killed in a car accident while he was returning home from Christmas shopping right after he got off from work.

Usually I completely panic about presentations but in this case I'm more worried about the outcome of my poem rather than the presentation itself. If I could get your opinions on my poem or any suggestions on changes I should make to it, PLEASE feel free to post them here. It'll be very much appreciated!!

A December To Remember

A dreadful day came about one December
One that I shall forever remember
Since nobody else knows
This is how the story goes…

A dreary December afternoon had dropped by
Giving no warning that someone special was to die
A little girl sat by the window enjoying the incoming breeze
Never having felt so much at ease

Soon to arrive home would be her treasure
The distance between them but a measure
Hours continued to come and go by
The little girl let out a worried sigh

Why was Daddy so late today?
Where had he gone so far away?
Her stomach worryingly began to churn
But out of love she still awaited his return

The moon rose high into the night sky
Overlooking the earth below like a gleaming eye
The girl's hopes rose as lights flashed in the driveway
The lights were not her father's car, much to her dismay

She could hear Death's rotting hands knocking on the door
The cold essence of his breath embracing her forevermore
As the girl’s mother opened the door with a frown
Gazing upon two gloomy officers looking down

Trying to think of a kinder way
To share what they had to say
Knowing it was anything but good news
Their words could only hurt and confuse

Reality itself became a car crash
Suddenly shattering within a flash
The lights became a flurry of red and blue
Death's hands bidding the little girl adieu

As the policemen returned to their domain
Leaving the little girl behind to go insane
The sadness and shock was too much for her
Leaving her thoughts to drown within this disaster

Nine years come and go...
The now sixteen-year-old girl gazes out of the same window
As a thought crosses her mind, recalling that day nine years ago
Out of all six cars involved, why did Daddy have to go?
 
Last edited:

vj288

not actually Fiona Apple
That was really, really good!! It makes my poems look like total crap. It's so easy to read, everything flows really nice and the mood is set from the first line and the whole time you know something is gonna happen. Really good.
 

Blinkers

Active member
That was very touching...

I lost my Dad recently, and it took me a few attempts to read it all the way through.

Maybe one day I'll be able to put into words how I feel, but that won't be for a while.

Great poem - well done :)
 

MaliceInWickedland

Well-known member
That was very touching...

I lost my Dad recently, and it took me a few attempts to read it all the way through.

Maybe one day I'll be able to put into words how I feel, but that won't be for a while.

Great poem - well done :)

I'm sorry for your loss, and thank you very much, I appreciate it :)
 
Hey, what a terrible loss to you at a young age ::(:

I would suggest considering to rewrite the last verse to something like:

Years come and go
As I gaze out that same window
A thought crosses my mind etc etc

It jumps it into the first person and leaves no doubt who this happened to - ends it with impact (also time proofs it for future use if you don't mention how long ago)

Watch for word repetion (eg rose), use an online thesaurus to find a good alt or leave it in and use it for effect (moon rose.......hopes rose with it)

:)
 

MaliceInWickedland

Well-known member
That was really, really good!! It makes my poems look like total crap. It's so easy to read, everything flows really nice and the mood is set from the first line and the whole time you know something is gonna happen. Really good.

Aww don't say that, I'm sure your poems are really good. I write a lot of poetry but this one is probably the only one I consider to be good IMO. Regardless, thank you very much, I appreciate the constructive criticism :D
 

MaliceInWickedland

Well-known member
Hey, what a terrible loss to you at a young age ::(:

I would suggest considering to rewrite the last verse to something like:

Years come and go
As I gaze out that same window
A thought crosses my mind etc etc

It jumps it into the first person and leaves no doubt who this happened to - ends it with impact (also time proofs it for future use if you don't mention how long ago)

Watch for word repetion (eg rose), use an online thesaurus to find a good alt or leave it in and use it for effect (moon rose.......hopes rose with it)

:)

Thanks a bunch!! This is what constructive criticism should look like :D
 

vj288

not actually Fiona Apple
Awww, I'm sorry ::(:
I really appreciate your reply though. Reminds me that there are still good people out there with genuine feelings.

You know half your class is going to be in tears when your done, right? And probably your teacher too. It's that good.
 
Top