I think this question gets at the ambivalence we feel about our avoidant tendencies. I have asked myself countless times whether I truly want to interact with people or would really rather be alone. Do I want to change? I tell myself different things. At times I feel a desperate desire to connect, but it seems impossible through the conventions of social interaction. Of course having no friends makes me unhappy, so I want to change, but I don't want to be the fake and awkward sort of person I would need to be to take the steps toward interaction. Unfortunately it is not just a matter of "forcing" myself through the awkward part until interaction supposedly becomes smoother; I have tried this and systematic effort has rarely led to genuine connection. I feel like the bluff is called fairly early on and I end up sneaking away- I can't maintain the necessary facades for long enough to get truly comfortable with anyone.
I wonder if my weirdness and isolation are the result of something deeper than just "social anxiety", something that can't be changed with self-help exercises and which it might be untrue to my nature to try to change. Sometimes it seems that I am just oriented differently from most people and am therefore uninterested in or clueless about what people are saying and doing in most social situations. As a result I have nothing to say and stay in my head. I feel bad about being distant and sometimes try to say something to appear normal, but what I say is insincere and comes across as awkward and stiff. I only make the effort out of feelings of guilt, self-consciousness about being aloof, and not wanting people to think I am snubbing them, or that I am completely boring or brain dead. When my attempts at socializing fall flat I feel even more self-conscious, inadequate and ill at ease, wondering why I have nothing genuine to contribute. I find it makes more sense not to put myself in these situations at all, since they result in no enjoyment or connection, and I feel that my presence makes others uncomfortable. But making no effort to reach out leads to depressive isolation, not to mention limits my professional prospects.
I do still want connection and I want to be able to enjoy the company of people occasionally, so how can I achieve this without exposing myself to such fruitless, humiliating experiences? Obviously I want and need to change, but I don't believe, even if I could become socially graceful, that ordinary social interactions would lead me to what I am really looking for. Maybe that is true for others who habitually avoid social situations- we know that avoiding perpetuates the dissatisfaction and loneliness, but we also know there is little or nothing to be gained from throwing ourselves out there. Is there an effective way to achieve connection that doesn't involve so much failure and that allows us to more readily affirm ourselves? Is the discomfort we usually feel around people an indication that society's established routes toward relationships just don't make sense for the way we think? Or is social anxiety nothing but a weakness to overcome? I've heard others talk of achieving self-acceptance- including accepting our introversion- and I think that is key, but how do you reach out in a way that comes from self-acceptance rather than a fear of disappointing others?