Odo
Banned
Nothing can change the past, that's certain. But punishment by example might stop similar things in the future. Nobody will bring that punishment back in this era I'm quite certain. I hope he gets what's coming to him...
I know that your journal isn't necessarily the place for debates about crime and punishment, but I don't think that medieval punishments work. When Ariel Castro did what he did, he probably wasn't thinking that he would ever get caught... or maybe he wasn't thinking about it at all. I don't think he was thinking 'I want to do this because I know that if I do get caught, nothing bad will happen to me'... he was just thinking 'I want to do this and I know it's wrong but I don't care'.
This is why the death penalty doesn't work as a deterrent either... people will always commit crimes, no matter what the penalty is. On the other hand, I don't think the death penalty is the worst thing that you could do to someone and I'd say that Ariel Castro is getting the worst possible thing done to him.
And seriously, the Supermax prisons are pretty awful... it's basically an ongoing torture that breaks you down psychologically-- they can strip you naked and leave you like that for days in your cell, there's no cable TV, no Internet, and sometimes you end up in an outdoor cage wearing nothing... and you're basically isolated ALL THE TIME, with zero control over anything. It's basically like being crucified, except you're comfortable enough not to die. The prisoners end up cutting themselves to the point where they need to have their limbs amputated, because it's the only way to feel anything.
Here's an article:
Supermax prisons: 21st century asylums - Opinion - Al Jazeera English