Oh it's easy, don't worry. I set it for 7:30 PST right now, if that doesn't work for anyone I can change it though. Basically, it's like picking teams in gym class. When you're up, you pick the player you want most of those left, easy peasy. You're going to want players who have the best stats, you can look on the site for the ones I set up for our league to count. (like hits and era, and not things like hbp and balks). Don't worry, it seems like you're in good company, a few others have never done this before either!