I have a hard time gauging when it's ok to move beyond the safe stuff. I tend to let other people lead the conversation, so if they don't lead, it just sorta dies out. And then I'm left wondering if they found me dreadfully boring or if they suffer the same problem as me.
Hey Moa, you can learn to look for nonverbal cues. There are actually books about this!!
People show excitement and interest in different ways - tone of voice, eye contact (or sometimes lack of it too, if they're shy hehe) How they move and stand etc. And if they come and initiate something (or reply/talk with you) next time etc. Basically just look for interaction patterns...
When someone is shy or reserved or only talks about the boring stuff, I'll wonder if they have the same issues as me or just don't want to talk to me.
Yeah, I sometimes wonder that too. Since reading on this forum, I assume that probably it's a) lots of really cool people can have sa too!!
I assume people who don't have SA think people like us are boring, awkward, weird.
Not neccessarily!! They can also think you're 'quiet' and 'calm/peaceful' (LOL!) or just 'interesting' and 'mysterious'!!
Maybe they can also think someone with sa is 'arrogant/aloof' or 'self-sufficient/not interested' (with already enough friends and social circle elsewhere) when one might be just shy. So if you're pleasant to them, they can change that perception.
Some good examples+info in this thread, by Patrick and Marie and Coyote especially!!
Think of it like 'tuning the guitars/instruments' and then playing real tunes... you can do both or either...
You start with 'warm up'/fine-tuning (=looking for common interests and/or responsiveness, if people even wanna talk) when you get to know someone well, then you can move on to more interesting/in-depth topics... Smalltalk is just a 'step' toward more meaningful conversation.. (Or just a way of saying, 'Hey you, I think you're interesting and I care'... to an older lady neighbour or such.. It doesn't need to go anywhere if you or they are too busy for more...)