You probably have to mix in confident and outgoing to effectively be the weird guy everyone likes. Quiet and withdrawn mixed with weird tends to be a recipe for disaster.
I have to agree with this. Keep learning how to build your confidence and eventually you'll feel yourself more "approachable". It's not an easy task, I know, but it's worth a try.
As for the topic, sometimes I feel like this due to my unusual "paranoia" (read: anxiety) and I feel like people will only like me If I pretend to be somebody else I'm not and start behaving accordingly.
However, as I keep "living and learning" with Life, is that there's always a place in this world for "misfit" people (like this very site is for me, heh), which make us feel ourselves at "home sweet home" (at least on-line).
Remember that every human being is unique on its own way with different tastes and personalities, and that's completely normal.
Some people are more comfortable to live on their own while other people want to socialize and meet new friends.
Therefore, even I don't "fit in" in a certain group, I'll either find other group who matches my personality or find no group at all, seeing "socialization" nothing more than a "burden".
I think that "fitting in" boils down to:
- With who we really want to associate with;
- Our self-image;
- And specially our personality.
(I hope I was clear enough with this post, heh.)