A bit excessive

Etbow23

Well-known member
Hey everyone,
I just wanted your opinion on this issue--in my health class, the teacher is pretty nice and the class has been pretty interesting. Last class, someone sent around a note asking, well not asking, but rather telling to write down the amount of money you want to donate for a teacher's gift and what you're going to bring in terms of food/drink because whoever wrote the note wants to plan a party for our last class before the exam (I guess the professor approved this?).

Everyone else was writing $5 and also food/drinks, most of them homemade baked stuff or like chicken meals (wow expensive), so I basically wrote the same thing, though I thought that was a bit much ($5 X everyone in the class?) Also the fact that whoever wrote the note didn't ask but rather told "Write down what you need to bring next week" bugged me...

Then I get an e-mail today from the person, entitled "ticher gift" - yes, she spelled teacher "ticher" and pretty "prity"- asking if anyone wanted to give more money because on the list she had $80 so far and she wanted to buy a watch at Macy's that was normally $225 but on sale for $145!

I mean, I want to do something nice for the teacher, but I feel that this is excessive for a teacher's gift. I work minimum wage, so $5 plus money to buy food/drinks or bake something at home is a lot for me. I would feel comfortable doing one or the other, or just giving $2 or something...which would probably add up to a nice $60 or $70 gift card with everyone in the class.

I really don't want to go to next class if it's a party--I hate group social situations and basically everyone in that class is just an acquaintance. I will feel awkward, and I also think it's crazy how this person wants to buy a $145 watch for the teacher. Just pushy in my opinion. I am considering not going to the last class, but the teacher deducts points for an absence (I have a good grade, so it probably won't matter, but..)

Okay do you think I'm being stingy/selfish?? Or is this a bit much. Like I said, I'd be happy getting something or donating a couple bucks, but I'm prbly going to have to spend over $10 or more including the gift money and food/drinks so I don't look like an ass showing up with one bag of chips or something.
 
Last edited:
This is a bit tough. Sounds like the teacher made quite the impression on the class. The expensive watch.

I'd say go. At least it will be a way to work on social exposure. Awkward no doubt. Something to build on it could become.

As for the cash, you're right. People may think you are selfish. It is your money, not theirs. Give what you will. If I really enjoy the teacher I'd have zero troubles increasing my donation for the gift.

Food wise, meh. Bring some or don't. Drink, bring something to drink at least.

Yeah, go to it.
 

coyote

Well-known member
situations like these are "give what you can"

don't feel obligated to donate more than you are able to - just do what you can

and even if you can't contribute as much as everyone else, you should still go to the party - you are a part of the class

have fun
 

MikeyC

Well-known member
situations like these are "give what you can"
Pretty much this. If you can't afford to give $5 + other things because you work minimum wage, then what else can you do? I'm sure you'd like to do something nice for the teacher, as well, but everyone has their limitations.
 

Mickery

Well-known member
I find it hard to believe even half of the people asked will increase the amount that much.
 
Top